Homes Under $500,000 in Payson, Utah

Search Homes
Price
Property type
Home Features
More

Filters

Finding an affordable home in Utah County doesn't mean sacrificing quality or community charm. Payson offers an excellent selection of homes under $500K, making it an attractive option for first-time buyers, growing families, and anyone seeking value in a welcoming small-town setting. Located along the I-15 corridor with stunning mountain views on both sides, Payson combines rural tranquility with convenient access to larger cities like Provo and Spanish Fork, both just a short drive away.

This price range in Payson typically includes a variety of options, from cozy starter homes perfect for young families to spacious properties with room to grow. Many homes in this range feature generous lot sizes, giving you space for gardens, outdoor recreation, or simply enjoying the beautiful Utah landscape. The community is known for its excellent schools, safe neighborhoods, and strong sense of community, with popular local events like the Scottish Festival and Onion Days bringing residents together throughout the year.

Browse our current listings of homes under $500K in Payson to discover what this charming Utah town has to offer. Each property listed includes detailed information, photos, and key features to help you find your ideal home. Our experienced local agents know the Payson market inside and out and are ready to help you navigate your home search, schedule tours, and make a competitive offer when you find the perfect match.

View Homes Under $500K in Payson, Utah


To buy in Payson, Utah call us directly at 801-845-3989


84 Homes For Sale in PAYSON Utah

1284 N 1400 E #05-15, Payson UT 84651

1284 N 1400 E #05-15
Payson UT 84651

3% INCENTIVE! Home is finished and ready to move in. FIBER INTERNET INCLUDED in HOA FEE. This 3 bedroom with a UNFINISHED BASEMENT. HOA - END ROW TOWNHOME is be...

  • 2513 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$419,262

1333 S 1050 W, Payson UT 84651

1333 S 1050 W
Payson UT 84651





  • 2614 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 3

  • 2

$470,000

1963 W 1150 S #1032, Payson UT 84651

1963 W 1150 S #1032
Payson UT 84651

Available in April! The Alder plan in our brand new Hiatt Creek community in Payson offers dramatic open-to above family room w/verticle railing @ stairs. Kitch...

  • 1957 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$402,775

412 S GOOSENEST DR, Payson UT 84651

412 S GOOSENEST DR
Payson UT 84651

Estimated taxes are currently unavailable. Property was recently subdivided and assigned a new tax ID for the 2026 tax year. Taxes have not yet been assessed un...

  • 0.36 Acres

$229,000

1152 W 1000 S, Payson UT 84651

1152 W 1000 S
Payson UT 84651

Open House 2/14/26 11:00 am to 2:00 pm. Discover the perfect blend of convenience and low-maintenance living in this charming 2-story twin home! Ideally situate...

  • 1832 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$470,000

1045 S 1700 W #311, Payson UT 84651

1045 S 1700 W #311
Payson UT 84651

MAIN LEVEL CONDO! Centrally located with plenty of amenities. Near freeway, dining, and shopping. Features new flooring through out (all carpet has been replace...

  • 1215 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

$269,900

426 S GOOSENEST DR, Payson UT 84651

426 S GOOSENEST DR
Payson UT 84651

IMPROVED LOT Prime 0.26-acre lot on the desirable east bench of Payson with beautiful mountain views and a quiet setting. Great opportunity to build your custom...

  • 0.26 Acres

$245,000

1621 N 1300 E, Payson UT 84651

1621 N 1300 E
Payson UT 84651

Stylish and modern 2-bedroom, 2-bath townhome designed for comfortable, low-maintenance living. Open-concept layout with abundant natural light and a clean, con...

  • 1428 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 3

  • 2

$319,900

1292 N 1400 E #04-14, Payson UT 84651

1292 N 1400 E #04-14
Payson UT 84651

3% INCENTIVE! Home is finished and ready to move in. FIBER INTERNET INCLUDED in HOA FEE. This 3 bedroom with a UNFINISHED BASEMENT. HOA Includes High-Speed Fibe...

  • 2513 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$394,950

1045 S 1700 W #520, Payson UT 84651

1045 S 1700 W #520
Payson UT 84651

Well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, dining, and outdoor recreation, this condo offers low-maintenance liv...

  • 1245 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

$265,000

4.9k

1287 N 1390 E #25-96, Payson UT 84651

1287 N 1390 E #25-96
Payson UT 84651

FIBER INTERNET INCLUDED in HOA FEE - SELLING FAST - Estimated to be completed Mid-February- HOA Includes High-Speed Fiber Internet - Why settle for a condo when...

  • 1543 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$346,764

339 N 500 E, Payson UT 84651

339 N 500 E
Payson UT 84651

Builder special single family lot! this .24 acre lot has so much potential. the lot is in a great area very close to downtown Payson and other amenities! the lo...

  • 0.24 Acres

$265,000

299 N 1070 E, Payson UT 84651

299 N 1070 E
Payson UT 84651

Looking for the perfect building lot to build your single level living haven. Mount Loafer Flats is the perfect 55+ community for you to build what you have bee...

  • 0.06 Acres

$160,000

742 W 400 S, Payson UT 84651

742 W 400 S
Payson UT 84651

Discover the potential of this 1,966 sq. ft. rambler/ranch style home located in the heart of Payson. Priced at $400,000, this residence offers a functional lay...

  • 1966 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 2

  • 1

$390,000

10.0k

1641 N 1320 E, Payson UT 84651

1641 N 1320 E
Payson UT 84651

Be sure to check out the 3D tour. This stunning end-unit townhome shows like a 10 and is perfectly situated on the north end of Payson and right on the Salem/Pa...

  • 1952 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$384,990

1163 S 730 W, Payson UT 84651

1163 S 730 W
Payson UT 84651

Spacious 4-Bed Rambler with a brand new roof in the Heart of Payson Discover the perfect blend of comfort and capability in this charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom ...

  • 2080 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 2

$447,000

NEW - 5 HOUR AGO
846 S 880 W, Payson UT 84651

846 S 880 W
Payson UT 84651

There is more than meets the eye with this remodeled rambler! All the work has been done for you ! Plenty of space for a growing family and a yard ready to play...

  • 2160 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 2

$499,999

433 E 450 N, Payson UT 84651

433 E 450 N
Payson UT 84651

LUXURY Home in NESTLED in secluded little pocket of town. Classy and timeless. Beautiful finishes. fireplace, two toned paint, quartz counters, upgraded exterio...

  • 2536 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$399,999

25.0k

228 E UTAH AVE, Payson UT 84651

228 E UTAH AVE
Payson UT 84651

Historic Payson Charm with Modern Updates. This beautifully maintained turn-of-the-century home blends timeless character with thoughtful updates throughout. Th...

  • 2072 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 2

$499,850

574 N 450 E, Payson UT 84651

574 N 450 E
Payson UT 84651

Nestled in a quiet, established Northern Payson neighborhood, this beautiful 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of peace and accessibility. I...

  • 2220 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 4

  • 2

$499,900

10.1k

977 E 100 S, Payson UT 84651

977 E 100 S
Payson UT 84651

Rare Park Place townhome now available! This beautifully remodeled home offers an open, bright floor plan with great natural light throughout. The main level fe...

  • 1264 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

$309,500

327 N 500 E, Payson UT 84651

327 N 500 E
Payson UT 84651

TWIN HOUSE INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY (BUILDERS SPECIAL) this land is one side of a twin lot, the other side is 2B (see listing). Enjoy your .28 acres of improved l...

  • 0.14 Acres

$135,000

1971 W 1150 S #1034, Payson UT 84651

1971 W 1150 S #1034
Payson UT 84651

Welcome to Hiatt Creek in Payson! The Alder combines thoughtful design with a stunning open-to-above great room, giving you a grand living space filled with nat...

  • 1791 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$400,025

523 1045 S 1700 #523, Payson UT 84651

523 1045 S 1700 #523
Payson UT 84651

Beautiful 3-bed, 2-bath townhome in a prime location with easy freeway access, shopping, dining, and amenities. Enjoy mountain views and a well-maintained, func...

  • 1245 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

$262,500

549 S MAIN ST, Payson UT 84651

549 S MAIN ST
Payson UT 84651

Great starter home with MOTHER-IN-LAW APARTMENT/POTENTIAL DUPLEX with a separate entrance! This home has it all! It features: newer furnace/water heater, large ...

  • 1456 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$409,900

1355 E 1360 N, Payson UT 84651

1355 E 1360 N
Payson UT 84651

Skip the construction timeline and step into this well-maintained three-level town-home offering functional, light-filled living space. Enjoy wide open views fr...

  • 2065 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 4

  • 2

$410,500

10.0k

1337 E 1670 N #817, Payson UT 84651

1337 E 1670 N #817
Payson UT 84651

0% Down-Payment Options Available. Contact Sales Associate for More Information *** The Silverbell plan greets guests with an open kitchen featuring a pantry, c...

  • 1496 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$344,990

588 W UTAH AVE, Payson UT 84651

588 W UTAH AVE
Payson UT 84651

Fantastic opportunity with built-in income potential! This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 1,700 sq ft of flexible living space on a generous .32-acre lo...

  • 1700 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 2

  • 2

$465,990

5.0k

1984 W 1150 S #1024, Payson UT 84651

1984 W 1150 S #1024
Payson UT 84651

Newly To-Be-Built townhome in our brand new Hiatt Creek/Payson community. The Willow floor plan features a spacious main levels with 9 ceilings, designed with a...

  • 1885 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$374,900

1334 N 1400 E #03-09, Payson UT 84651

1334 N 1400 E #03-09
Payson UT 84651

ROCK. BOTTOM. PRICE! Home is finished and ready to move in. FIBER INTERNET INCLUDED in HOA FEE. This 3 bedroom with a UNFINISHED BASEMENT. HOA Includes High-Spe...

  • 2513 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$383,053

16.1k

1972 W 1150 S #1027, Payson UT 84651

1972 W 1150 S #1027
Payson UT 84651

Welcome to our brand new Hiatt Creek community in Payson! The Willow floor plan features one of our largest main levels, designed with a spacious open layout an...

  • 1885 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$374,900

1304 E 1670 N #907, Payson UT 84651

1304 E 1670 N #907
Payson UT 84651

The main floor of the Boston paired home offers an open layout that flows from living and dining rooms into a large kitchen, complete with a center island and a...

  • 1438 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$384,990

10.0k

420 N 150 W, Payson UT 84651

420 N 150 W
Payson UT 84651

Great home in Payson, Utah. Square footage figures are provided as a courtesy estimate only and were obtained from County Records. Buyer is advised to obtain...

  • 2568 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 2

$455,000

332 N 500 E, Payson UT 84651

332 N 500 E
Payson UT 84651

*Click the Tour link to see a 3D Virtual Tour* This Charming and thoughtfully updated 2-bedroom single-family home in Payson, Utah! Located in desirable South U...

  • 912 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 1

$389,990

10.0k

1782 N 1240 E, Payson UT 84651

1782 N 1240 E
Payson UT 84651

!!Price Improvement!! - Motivated Sellers! Welcome to this move in ready beautifully maintained 2-year-old end-unit townhome offering the perfect blend of sty...

  • 1433 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$349,990

5.0k

1282 E 1700 N, Payson UT 84651

1282 E 1700 N
Payson UT 84651

This beautiful twin home features 3 bedroom, 2 1/2 baths, great open floor plan with quartz countertops, gas stove and large island, 9 foot ceilings. Youll love...

  • 1430 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$359,000

10.9k

1983 W 1150 S #1037, Payson UT 84651

1983 W 1150 S #1037
Payson UT 84651

Available in April! The Alder plan in our brand new Hiatt Creek community in Payson offers 3 bedrooms upstairs with dramatic open-to-below to downstairs family ...

  • 1957 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$419,275

1338 E 1280 N #08-30, Payson UT 84651

1338 E 1280 N #08-30
Payson UT 84651

FIBER INTERNET INCLUDED in HOA FEE - SELLING FAST - Estimated to be completed End-August- HOA Includes High-Speed Fiber Internet - Why settle for a condo when y...

  • 2031 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$408,241

1992 W 1150 S #1022, Payson UT 84651

1992 W 1150 S #1022
Payson UT 84651

Welcome to our brand new Hiatt Creek community in Payson! The Willow floor plan features one of our largest main levels, designed with a spacious open layout an...

  • 1885 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$363,653

876 S GREENRIDGE AVE, Payson UT 84651

876 S GREENRIDGE AVE
Payson UT 84651

Fantastic starter home that shows beautifully inside & out! Brand new roof (Feb 2025). Tons of storage with lighted crawl space + attic w/pull-down ladder. Enjo...

  • 1070 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 2

$286,000

Homes Under $500K in Payson

Looking for homes under $500k in Payson, Utah? We currently have 84 listings matching your criteria. New properties are added daily, so check back often or create a custom search to get notified of new listings.

Best Utah Real Estate Mobile App
MLS at your fingertips
Real-time updates
Listing Alerts
Interactive Map
Save your searches

Best Utah Real Estate

Your trusted MLS search companion

Accurate Data - Direct MLS feed for real-time listings
Privacy First - We never sell your personal data
Personalized - Custom alerts for your dream home
Easy to Use - Intuitive design for all users