Vacation Rental Properties for Sale in Garden City, Utah

Search Homes
Price
Property type
Home Features
More

Filters

Garden City, nestled along the pristine shores of Bear Lake, offers an exceptional opportunity for vacation rental property investment. This charming Utah community attracts thousands of visitors each year who come to experience the stunning turquoise waters known as the "Caribbean of the Rockies." Owning a vacation rental here means you can generate income during peak summer months and winter recreation seasons while also enjoying your own private retreat whenever you'd like to escape to the lake.

The vacation rental market in Garden City remains strong thanks to the area's year-round appeal. Summer guests flock to Bear Lake for boating, swimming, and the famous raspberry days celebration, while winter visitors enjoy snowmobiling and ice fishing. Properties close to the marina, beach access points, and downtown Garden City tend to perform particularly well as short-term rentals. Many owners find that their vacation properties not only pay for themselves but also provide a valuable asset that appreciates over time in this desirable lakeside location.

Browse our current selection of vacation rental properties in Garden City to find the perfect investment opportunity that matches your goals. Whether you're looking for a cozy cabin or a spacious lakefront home, our experienced agents understand the local market and can help you evaluate rental potential, zoning requirements, and seasonal trends. Contact us today to learn more about making your Bear Lake vacation rental dreams a reality.

View Vacation Rental Properties in Garden City, Utah


To buy in Garden City, Utah call us directly at 435-359-4332


105 Homes For Sale in GARDEN CITY Utah

NEW - 54 HOUR AGO
3525 S SWEETWATER PKWY #54, Garden City UT 84028

3525 S SWEETWATER PKWY #54
Garden City UT 84028

Custom built home on 2.44 acres in beautiful Bear Lake! Located in Sweetwater with views of Bear Lake and the mountains! Home is situated to maximize parking ...

  • 3559 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 4

  • 3

$1,100,000

673 N LOCHWOOD VW, Garden City UT 84028

673 N LOCHWOOD VW
Garden City UT 84028

Beautiful Bear Lake building lot in the Lochwood subdivision, in the heart of Garden City. SHORT TERM RENTALS ALLOWED! Popular rental area! Top row of the commu...

  • 0.12 Acres

$125,000

942 N NEWBERG DR #2, Garden City UT 84028

942 N NEWBERG DR #2
Garden City UT 84028

PRICED $25k BELOW RECENTLY SOLD UNITS IN COMPLEX. Already Booked with Nightly Rentals For 2026 - New Buyer to Enjoy Substantial Rental Income. NEWLY REMODELED T...

  • 1200 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 2

$349,000

2711 S DRIVER CIR, Garden City UT 84028

2711 S DRIVER CIR
Garden City UT 84028

Gently sloped building lot in cul-de-sac of lower Sweetwater. Next to Bear Lake Golf Course with protected views of Bear Lake and mountains. Great for a walkout...

  • 0.30 Acres

$109,000

427 W BLUEGRASS WAY, Garden City UT 84028

427 W BLUEGRASS WAY
Garden City UT 84028

Build your dream retreat or investment property on this prime Bear Lake lot! Located in a sought-after subdivision that allows nightly rentals, stunning mountai...

  • 0.31 Acres

$130,000

2759 S SERVICEBERRY DR, Garden City UT 84028

2759 S SERVICEBERRY DR
Garden City UT 84028

One acre building lot with excellent views of Bear Lake and surrounding mountains. Wildlife corridor adjacent to property for moose and deer. Bear Lake Golf Cou...

  • 1.00 Acres

$99,000

964 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR, Garden City UT 84028

964 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR
Garden City UT 84028

Wow! This coveted 1 acre homesite is southwest facing in a quiet cul-de-sac with a desirable gentle downhill slope perfect for a walkout, daylight basement belo...

  • 1.00 Acres

$245,000

980 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR, Garden City UT 84028

980 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR
Garden City UT 84028

Wow! This coveted 1 acre homesite is southeast facing in a quiet cul-de-sac with a desirable gentle downhill slope perfect for a walkout, daylight basement belo...

  • 1.00 Acres

$245,000

2292 S ASPEN LOOP, Garden City UT 84028

2292 S ASPEN LOOP
Garden City UT 84028

Stunning panoramic views of Bear Lake and the valley with year round access from this Rustic Bear Lake log cabin . Located on a large treed 1.88 ac lot in upper...

  • 3328 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 4

  • 2

$799,000

902 N NEWBURG #4, Garden City UT 84028

902 N NEWBURG #4
Garden City UT 84028

MOTIVATED SELLER! Now offering an exclusive end unit Newberg condo at Harbor Village with the best views in all of Bear Lake. Brand new exterior deck. Overlooki...

  • 1200 Sq Ft

  • 2

  • 2

$369,000

10.0k

1470 N TRAPPER LOOP, Garden City UT 84028

1470 N TRAPPER LOOP
Garden City UT 84028

Excellent view lot in the gated community of Swan Creek. Great location... just minutes to Bear Lake State Park Marina and downtown Garden City for "famous" an...

  • 0.13 Acres

$65,000

39 W TAMARIND WAY, Garden City UT 84028

39 W TAMARIND WAY
Garden City UT 84028

OPEN HOUSE Saturday, January 31st 3:30-5:30pm and Sunday, February 1st 11am-3pm. This custom-built beauty is ready for you! If the perfect view of the lake fr...

  • 5145 Sq Ft

  • 5

  • 6

  • 3

$1,625,000

2584 S COUNTRY CLUB DR #12, Garden City UT 84028

2584 S COUNTRY CLUB DR #12
Garden City UT 84028

Clear Blue skies and Beautiful views of Blue Bear Lake. Great Location accessible Year round on paved road! There are 2 full kitchens/family rooms. 6 Bedrooms a...

  • 3754 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 4

  • 1

$879,000

35 E 150 S #402C, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #402C
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

559 N BLUE LAKE ST, Garden City UT 84028

559 N BLUE LAKE ST
Garden City UT 84028

Just moments from the shoreline and offered FULLY FURNISHED with approximately $25,000 in furniture included-making this a true turn-key opportunity. This well-...

  • 2075 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$430,000

538 W RASPBERRY PATCH RD, Garden City UT 84028

538 W RASPBERRY PATCH RD
Garden City UT 84028

Experience the Caribbean of the Rockies from this stunning 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath retreat in the heart of Garden City-now more desirable than ever thanks to its ex...

  • 2924 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 4

  • 2

$975,000

10.0k

2229 S BEACHCOMBER LN, Garden City UT 84028

2229 S BEACHCOMBER LN
Garden City UT 84028

Great Investment/Second Home!! Bear Lake offers incredible landscapes and scenery. You can enjoy the Lake, mountain biking, fishing, ice fishing, hiking, and m...

  • 3405 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 4

  • 2

$724,967

20.0k

37 WEDGE WAY, Garden City UT 84028

37 WEDGE WAY
Garden City UT 84028

4.8 STAR VRBO NIGHTLY RENTAL HOME! BUY NOW AND COLLECT THE SUMMER 2026 RENTS! TURNKEY READY TO GO. HAS GENERATED MORE THAN $200K IN RENTS OVER PAST 4 SUMMERS. ...

  • 4460 Sq Ft

  • 8

  • 5

  • 2

$799,900

15.0k

984 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR, Garden City UT 84028

984 S CROSSED ARROWS CIR
Garden City UT 84028

NEW PRICE!! Beautiful new home located in a quiet cul-de-sac in Eagle Feather at Shundahai. Surrounded by pines and quakies with views of BEAR LAKE. Features ...

  • 5062 Sq Ft

  • 8

  • 8

  • 3

$1,779,000

31.0k

140 W 150 S #D11, Garden City UT 84028

140 W 150 S #D11
Garden City UT 84028

Walking distance to the shore of Bear Lake. This beautiful FULLY FURNISHED townhome features 3 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms and plenty of space to entertain and spend...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 4

$495,900

3042 S CHUKAR DR, Garden City UT 84028

3042 S CHUKAR DR
Garden City UT 84028

Beautiful Sweetwater cabin with SHORT TERM RENTALS ALLOWED! Large .84 acre lot! Sleeps 24 comfortably! Great rental history and being sold FULLY FURNISHED! So m...

  • 3350 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 4

$925,000

20.0k

35 E 150 S #102B, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #102B
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$675,000

35 E 150 S, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S
Garden City UT 84028

Amazing Opportunity to own 16 luxury condos! Estimated to be complete in August. Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakes...

  • 26480 Sq Ft

  • 48

  • 48

$9,120,000

80.0k

568 BLUE LAKE ST #28, Garden City UT 84028

568 BLUE LAKE ST #28
Garden City UT 84028

Unit #28. Welcome to your BRAND NEW short term rental approved lakeside sanctuary in the heart of Garden City! This beautifully appointed End Unit townhome offe...

  • 1807 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

  • 2

$364,900

447 W SUNBURST DR, Garden City UT 84028

447 W SUNBURST DR
Garden City UT 84028

Beautiful views of the lake and the mountains. Ride your UTV, bike or snowmobile right from your door and experience all that Bear Lake offer. There is no HOA ...

  • 0.73 Acres

$199,000

35 E 150 S #202B, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #202B
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$675,000

2520 S ASPEN LOOP, Garden City UT 84028

2520 S ASPEN LOOP
Garden City UT 84028

Rare opportunity to own a 1.91-acre view lot in Sweetwater overlooking beautiful Bear Lake in Garden City. This premier homesite offers sweeping panoramic views...

  • 1.91 Acres

$179,000

402 W BLUEBELL DR, Garden City UT 84028

402 W BLUEBELL DR
Garden City UT 84028

Your dream Bear Lake getaway awaits! This stunning 6-bedroom, 5-bath vacation home will be constructed in the scenic hills of Sweetwater community in Garden Cit...

  • 3072 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 5

$750,000

758 N CAMBRY DR, Garden City UT 84028

758 N CAMBRY DR
Garden City UT 84028

Bear Lake Genuine log home in Harbor Village, Garden City, Utah Built in 2004 Overlooking the State marina with a gorgeous view of Bear Lake! Perfect for person...

  • 4028 Sq Ft

  • 6

  • 3

$877,000

50.0k

166 E SAILORS WAY LN #9, Garden City UT 84028

166 E SAILORS WAY LN #9
Garden City UT 84028

Dont miss your chance to have a brand new to be built single family home at Bear Lake. Minutes from the beach with plenty of room for family and friends. Approv...

  • 3405 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 3

  • 2

$519,900

529 W RASPBERRY PATCH RD, Garden City UT 84028

529 W RASPBERRY PATCH RD
Garden City UT 84028

Fantastic Lot in Harbor Village Sub. Short term Rentals are allowed. Pool, Tennis, Basketball, and play area are part of the HOA. Just above the marina for grea...

  • 0.28 Acres

$129,900

35 E 150 S #401B, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #401B
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

35 E 150 S #202C, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #202C
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$675,000

35 E 150 S #301C, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #301C
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

35 E 150 S #302C, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #302C
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

35 E 150 S #402B, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #402B
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

35 E 150 S #401C, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #401C
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$690,000

35 E 150 S #101B, Garden City UT 84028

35 E 150 S #101B
Garden City UT 84028

Modern Luxury Condo Near Bear Lake Short term rental Approved Experience lakeside living at its finest in this stunning new condo development in Garden City, U...

  • 1655 Sq Ft

  • 3

  • 3

$675,000

3023 S GOLF COURSE DR, Garden City UT 84028

3023 S GOLF COURSE DR
Garden City UT 84028

Ready to move in! New lake house with spectacular views of Bear Lake with many custom features including: Large decks in front and back of home. Large open wind...

  • 2592 Sq Ft

  • 4

  • 3

  • 1

$875,000

10.0k

2176 S BEAR BLVD #421, Garden City UT 84028

2176 S BEAR BLVD #421
Garden City UT 84028

This turnkey 1-bedroom, 1-bath condo at Ideal Beach Resort is fully furnished and ready to enjoy yourself or offer as a nightly rental. The updated kitchen feat...

  • 600 Sq Ft

  • 1

  • 1

$340,000

10.0k

Vacation Rental Properties in Garden City

Looking for vacation rental properties in Garden City, Utah? We currently have 105 listings matching your criteria. New properties are added daily, so check back often or create a custom search to get notified of new listings.

Best Utah Real Estate Mobile App
MLS at your fingertips
Real-time updates
Listing Alerts
Interactive Map
Save your searches

Best Utah Real Estate

Your trusted MLS search companion

Accurate Data - Direct MLS feed for real-time listings
Privacy First - We never sell your personal data
Personalized - Custom alerts for your dream home
Easy to Use - Intuitive design for all users